One of the more unfortunate responses to the Nashville Statement (of which, to be clear, I am not a fan, despite being broadly in agreement with its ethical positions) is to complain that this statement is divisive. You can find the complaint here, for example, on a blog which I have on other ocassions found useful and encouraging. It's unfortunate because of two things: firstly, it complains that the statement does exactly what it aims to do; and secondly, it implicitly claims that division is always bad. The second claim is obviously the important one, and it doesn't work. The NT is full of commands to divide from people - off the top of my head, one might consider 1 Corinthians 5, or 2 Thessalonians 3:6. These two references are particularly pertinent, as they don't command division from people who take erroneous doctrinal stances, but from people who persist in ethically forbidden behaviour.
That helps with countering a particular form of the 'division is bad' argument, which makes it an issue of whether we believe in justification by faith. In the same post I linked earlier, you will find essentially this argument: if you divide from anyone over anything other than faith in Christ, you are saying that justification requires faith in Christ and this other thing, in this case a particular take on sexual ethics. And therefore you are denying the heart of the gospel.
It's worth picking over the logic. The idea is that if I divide from someone else who professes faith in Christ, then I am claiming that this person is not a Christian, and therefore I am saying, or at least implying, that I think they're not justified. Therefore I am making justification depend on faith in Christ and right doctrine or behaviour, and this will not do.
Let me counter some of that. Firstly, it is worth noting that the NT is clear that certain kinds of behaviour rule out inheriting the Kingdom of God, regardless of the faith you profess - see Galatians 5:19-21 and 1 Corinthians 6:9-10. Without getting into the detail of how that works, it seems clear that if your understanding of justification sola fide makes these verses untenable, your understanding is wrong. Secondly, division from another person who professes faith in Christ ought not to be understood as a final judgement on them as to their justification - by what power or right could we possible pass such a judgement? It is more like a warning shot. It says 'friend, we consider your doctrine or behaviour to be such that we cannot regard you as a true Christian; and therefore we call you to consider whether you are in the right with God, and to repent'. That is a severe thing to say, but it could be a mercy if it brings repentance!
Thirdly, in the final analysis, this is just a rehash of the Counter-Reformation calumnies against justification by faith alone, but given a perversely positive spin. The Counter-Ref claimed that Protestants taught that so long as you believed in Jesus you could behave as you liked - there was no motive for ethical living, because your faith would guarantee you salvation regardless of what you did. Of course, the Roman apologists of this era were appalled at such a suggestion. Now, though, it is expressed as if this were a positive thing: we can all just disagree about sexual ethics, because it doesn't really matter what you do, so long as you believe in Christ! But this is a desperate caricature of the beautiful doctrine of justification by faith alone. If you think that justification by faith alone means 'trust in Christ and it doesn't matter how you live', then you have missed the point. The person who is justified by faith in Christ is given a heart to obey Christ. The person who does not obey Christ does not love Christ, does not trust Christ. This is all in the New Testament, front and centre. You can deny the gospel by your behaviour, as well as by your doctrine.
I hope the Nashville Statement disappears soon. I don't think it's fit for purpose. It lacks theological rigour and gospel tone. But there is a serious need for division in the church. If we take the NT warnings about ethics and the Kingdom seriously - read again some of the verses I've linked above! - the least loving thing we can do is to try to fudge the issue. Eternal life is at stake. We must be clear.
Inside my head there are thoughts. The thoughts are shiny. Their orange shiny-ness shows through in my hair.
Showing posts with label justification. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justification. Show all posts
Saturday, September 02, 2017
Friday, May 12, 2017
Faith in what?
When we (Protestants) say that people are 'justified by faith', what do we mean? Are we declared righteous on the basis of a general credulity? Is it faith, per se, that justifies, or is there a particular character to justifying faith?
John Owen, a man not much given to brevity, defines the object of justifying faith as "the Lord Jesus Christ himself, as the ordinance of God, in his work of mediation for the recovery and salvation of lost sinners, and as unto that end proposed in the promise of the gospel". And he goes on to helpfully unpack that in four dimensions, which we might summarise thus:
1. "The Lord Jesus Christ himself" - that is to say, the faith which justifies is personal faith, trust in Christ himself. It is not mere assent to facts. We all know what it means to trust a person; that is what faith is, and the trusted person is the Lord Jesus Christ.
2. "as the ordinance of God" - in other words, faith in Christ views him not as a general person, but as the person given by God the Father to bring about our salvation. So justifying faith is not only grounded in the person of Christ as the Son; it also looks to the Father as the one who sends him. Knowing that Christ is the one sent by God for the purpose of recovering and saving lost sinners, those who are justified put their trust in him.
3. "for the recovery and salvation of lost sinners" - the effect of Christ's work is salvation, and so justifying faith has an eye on that as its end goal. (Owen fudges a little here, to my mind, arguing that although justifying faith ought to lead one to believe that one's own sins are forgiven, that does not belong to its essential nature - I struggle with that; how can one trust Christ for salvation and not trust that one is actually saved?) Still, justifying faith is not directly faith that one is justified - this could well be mere presumption. It is faith in Christ as the one sent to effect justification.
4. "as unto that end proposed in the promise" - faith which justifies is faith which looks at God's promises extended to us in the gospel and leans on Christ in the promises. All the promises of the gospel - every good thing which God offers to believers - is found in Christ and based in his work as mediator. Therefore, faith which regards the promises is faith which can be traced to Christ himself.
Justifying faith is trust in Jesus as the one sent by the Father for our good; trust in Jesus as the one who came for our salvation; trust in Jesus as the one in whom all God's promises are yes and amen.
John Owen, a man not much given to brevity, defines the object of justifying faith as "the Lord Jesus Christ himself, as the ordinance of God, in his work of mediation for the recovery and salvation of lost sinners, and as unto that end proposed in the promise of the gospel". And he goes on to helpfully unpack that in four dimensions, which we might summarise thus:
1. "The Lord Jesus Christ himself" - that is to say, the faith which justifies is personal faith, trust in Christ himself. It is not mere assent to facts. We all know what it means to trust a person; that is what faith is, and the trusted person is the Lord Jesus Christ.
2. "as the ordinance of God" - in other words, faith in Christ views him not as a general person, but as the person given by God the Father to bring about our salvation. So justifying faith is not only grounded in the person of Christ as the Son; it also looks to the Father as the one who sends him. Knowing that Christ is the one sent by God for the purpose of recovering and saving lost sinners, those who are justified put their trust in him.
3. "for the recovery and salvation of lost sinners" - the effect of Christ's work is salvation, and so justifying faith has an eye on that as its end goal. (Owen fudges a little here, to my mind, arguing that although justifying faith ought to lead one to believe that one's own sins are forgiven, that does not belong to its essential nature - I struggle with that; how can one trust Christ for salvation and not trust that one is actually saved?) Still, justifying faith is not directly faith that one is justified - this could well be mere presumption. It is faith in Christ as the one sent to effect justification.
4. "as unto that end proposed in the promise" - faith which justifies is faith which looks at God's promises extended to us in the gospel and leans on Christ in the promises. All the promises of the gospel - every good thing which God offers to believers - is found in Christ and based in his work as mediator. Therefore, faith which regards the promises is faith which can be traced to Christ himself.
Justifying faith is trust in Jesus as the one sent by the Father for our good; trust in Jesus as the one who came for our salvation; trust in Jesus as the one in whom all God's promises are yes and amen.
Friday, August 21, 2015
Jesus, justifier and sanctifier
In Church Dogmatics IV/2 p499f. Barth deals with the relationship between justification (God's declaration that those who trust in Christ are righteous) and sanctification (God's separation of those who trust in Christ to be holy and live out holiness). It's one of the most practically important issues in theology, and one where I think we have a lot to learn.
Barth takes us back to Chalcedon, and the relationship between the two natures - divine and human - of Christ. The two natures are undivided but also unconfused. That is to say, they cannot be separated, but neither can they be merged. Christ's divinity is never without his humanity, and vice versa - but his divinity is not his humanity, and his humanity is not his divinity. For Barth this has direct bearing on the question of justification and sanctification, because the architecture of his doctrine of reconciliation works like this: Christ as the God who humbles himself is the justifier; Christ as the man who is exalted is the sanctifier. In his one action - which takes in his whole life, death, resurrection, and ascension - Jesus the God-man is Christ the justifier-sanctifier.
The dangers of confusing justification and sanctification exist on both sides. If justification is merged into sanctification, as Barth suggests occurs in much Roman Catholic teaching, then faith in Christ will disappear into the works of the Christian, and Christian confidence in the gift of righteousness given in Christ will be lost. If sanctification is merged into justification, the necessity of good works may be lost in a one-sided emphasis on the judicial verdict of God.
On the other hand, the danger of separating justification and sanctification looms on both sides. To think of justification without sanctification is to imagine that God's declaration of righteousness does not actually lead to holiness; it thus imagines a strange asymmetry in God's work. A God on the one hand concerned with righteousness to the point of giving his Son is on the other hand unconcerned with human behaviour. But to think of sanctification without justification is to think an impossibility, since sanctification means walking in confident obedience before God, and this simply cannot be without a firm assurance springing from the verdict of righteousness pronounced in Jesus. How, after all, could I be joyfully obedient when even my obedience is so obviously inadequate?
I think probably the great danger in the sorts of churches I know is that justification and sanctification are both preached, but they are preached in isolation. My observation is that the gospel is often taken to mean justification, whilst sanctification is perhaps thought of as a more or less distant consequence of the gospel. In practice, that means that when we preach obedience it often seems disconnected from the gospel. It is not then surprising that some in our churches treat any preaching of the need for action as legalism and anti-gospel, because of course even the right preaching of the right actions is indeed anti-gospel in so far as it proceeds from an autonomous principle of obedience rather than the gospel.
The answer, I think, is to see with Barth that justification and sanctification are one in Christ, both achieved by him in his life, death, resurrection, and ascension. This means talking about Jesus as much when we are discussing the need for, and motivation and power for, human obedience as we do when we are discussing the gift of righteousness.
Barth takes us back to Chalcedon, and the relationship between the two natures - divine and human - of Christ. The two natures are undivided but also unconfused. That is to say, they cannot be separated, but neither can they be merged. Christ's divinity is never without his humanity, and vice versa - but his divinity is not his humanity, and his humanity is not his divinity. For Barth this has direct bearing on the question of justification and sanctification, because the architecture of his doctrine of reconciliation works like this: Christ as the God who humbles himself is the justifier; Christ as the man who is exalted is the sanctifier. In his one action - which takes in his whole life, death, resurrection, and ascension - Jesus the God-man is Christ the justifier-sanctifier.
The dangers of confusing justification and sanctification exist on both sides. If justification is merged into sanctification, as Barth suggests occurs in much Roman Catholic teaching, then faith in Christ will disappear into the works of the Christian, and Christian confidence in the gift of righteousness given in Christ will be lost. If sanctification is merged into justification, the necessity of good works may be lost in a one-sided emphasis on the judicial verdict of God.
On the other hand, the danger of separating justification and sanctification looms on both sides. To think of justification without sanctification is to imagine that God's declaration of righteousness does not actually lead to holiness; it thus imagines a strange asymmetry in God's work. A God on the one hand concerned with righteousness to the point of giving his Son is on the other hand unconcerned with human behaviour. But to think of sanctification without justification is to think an impossibility, since sanctification means walking in confident obedience before God, and this simply cannot be without a firm assurance springing from the verdict of righteousness pronounced in Jesus. How, after all, could I be joyfully obedient when even my obedience is so obviously inadequate?
I think probably the great danger in the sorts of churches I know is that justification and sanctification are both preached, but they are preached in isolation. My observation is that the gospel is often taken to mean justification, whilst sanctification is perhaps thought of as a more or less distant consequence of the gospel. In practice, that means that when we preach obedience it often seems disconnected from the gospel. It is not then surprising that some in our churches treat any preaching of the need for action as legalism and anti-gospel, because of course even the right preaching of the right actions is indeed anti-gospel in so far as it proceeds from an autonomous principle of obedience rather than the gospel.
The answer, I think, is to see with Barth that justification and sanctification are one in Christ, both achieved by him in his life, death, resurrection, and ascension. This means talking about Jesus as much when we are discussing the need for, and motivation and power for, human obedience as we do when we are discussing the gift of righteousness.
Saturday, August 07, 2010
Simul iustus et peccator (2)
Oh dear, this is getting more obscure in my mind instead of clearer. Nevertheless, I heroically press on with what is likely to be a series of questions rather than answers...
To push the dialectic theme a bit further, and perhaps to locate it at a deeper and more important place: What is the relationship between the righteousness of Christ and the righteous acts of the Christian?
Again, one could envisage a straightforward relationship, perhaps even a relationship of identity. I don't think Scripture allows us to tread that path. Christ's righteousness is once-for-all, and is now in heaven. He doesn't require our participation (in this sense) to complete who he is and what he has done. Jesus' righteousness and the Christian's righteous deeds cannot be identified in a straightforward manner at all.
I think I prefer to say - because I think this is what comes across in the Pauline writings especially - that the righteous deeds of the Christian are an answer (temporal, partial, inadequate, but nevertheless real) to the righteousness of Christ which is extended to the believer. Christ's righteousness (which is also my righteousness by faith) is one thing; my righteous acts are another thing, which relate to the former as a witness. To put it another way, an absolute monarch could make an absolute proclamation; if his subjects say 'yes' to it, it adds nothing to the proclamation, but merely shows their approval, their belief in the rightness of the proclamation. Does that make sense?
So I think there is a heavenly/earthly dialectic going on here. My righteousness is Christ, who is in heaven; my reply to that righteousness is righteous deeds.
But has anything really changed in me?
The answer is yes, but I won't write about it until Monday at least.
To push the dialectic theme a bit further, and perhaps to locate it at a deeper and more important place: What is the relationship between the righteousness of Christ and the righteous acts of the Christian?
Again, one could envisage a straightforward relationship, perhaps even a relationship of identity. I don't think Scripture allows us to tread that path. Christ's righteousness is once-for-all, and is now in heaven. He doesn't require our participation (in this sense) to complete who he is and what he has done. Jesus' righteousness and the Christian's righteous deeds cannot be identified in a straightforward manner at all.
I think I prefer to say - because I think this is what comes across in the Pauline writings especially - that the righteous deeds of the Christian are an answer (temporal, partial, inadequate, but nevertheless real) to the righteousness of Christ which is extended to the believer. Christ's righteousness (which is also my righteousness by faith) is one thing; my righteous acts are another thing, which relate to the former as a witness. To put it another way, an absolute monarch could make an absolute proclamation; if his subjects say 'yes' to it, it adds nothing to the proclamation, but merely shows their approval, their belief in the rightness of the proclamation. Does that make sense?
So I think there is a heavenly/earthly dialectic going on here. My righteousness is Christ, who is in heaven; my reply to that righteousness is righteous deeds.
But has anything really changed in me?
The answer is yes, but I won't write about it until Monday at least.
Friday, August 06, 2010
Simul iustus et peccator (1)
The relationship between righteousness and sinfulness in the Christian life has always been a big theological issue. More than that, it is a big existential issue for any Christian with any self-awareness at all. Particularly, it is an issue where our self-awareness and our gospel-awareness apparently come into conflict, or at least into such sharp tension that resolution seems beyond us. To state the problem simply, the gospel tells me I am righteous, but I find myself to be sinful. What am I to do with these apparently irreconcilable insights? I want to explore that in a few posts (I've not yet decided how many). For those with a smattering of Latin, or some knowledge of classic Protestant Orthodoxy, my answer will already be apparent, although I may want to develop it in a way that differs somewhat from the Orthodox statement.
Let me put down some foundations. It seems to me that there are two basic ways of approaching this problem, two ways of relating the Christian's righteousness and his or her sinfulness.
On the one hand, there are constructions in which these two things are placed on one plane. At its most crude, this is expressed as a sort of sliding scale. You experience a mix of righteousness and sinfulness because you are a mix of righteousness and sinfulness. You are partly righteous, partly sinful. Righteousness and sinfulness are, on this model, considered to be basically the same sort of thing, albeit the same sort of thing in an opposite configuration. Now, I would guess this view is hardly ever expressed in such a crude way as this, but I think we can detect it lying behind the traditional Roman Catholic approach, for example. On this view, baptism is the beginning of righteousness, the first infusion of righteousness into me as a subject. Throughout my Christian life, I should expect that my righteousness increases (with the concurrent decrease in my sinfulness) as I make use of the means of grace, especially of course the sacraments. Of course, should I neglect the means of grace, or entertain temptation in some way, I can expect the scale to slide the other way. This view has the benefit of being straightforward, making sense of our experience, and being practical, giving us instructions in dealing with our relative sinfulness.
Before any Roman Catholics jump on me for presenting their theology in such a crude, and frankly shabby, fashion - I know it isn't quite like that. But that is the tendency I see at the heart of it. Am I wrong?
The other basic approach is to say that there is some sort of dialectical approach to righteousness/sinfulness, something which places them on different planes, or at least which makes their relationship much more complex than a sliding scale. On this side we have to place all Protestant answers, which have typically stated that the Christian is in some way both righteous and sinful at one and the same time (simul iustus et peccator) without implying that righteousness and sinfulness can be considered as present in different relative measures in the Christian. The classic Reformed position, which sees the Christian as totally righteous with the imputed righteousness of Christ, and yet in themselves sinful, is a good example of this.
The two approaches - the straightforward and the dialectical - can be related in one system, and indeed probably must be. So, for example, the Reformed see a sliding scale in the Christian's worked out or experienced righteousness/sinfulness, whilst holding an ultimately dialectical view; the Roman Catholic sees the righteousness of Christ lying behind the sacraments in a way which cannot be made to slot into the straightforward view. Nevertheless, the two positions are basically different in their approach.
There is of course the Wesleyan view, which to my mind is just confused as to which position it holds. Probably it ultimately comes down on the dialectical side. As a historical note, you could argue that Lutheranism is characterised by a more pure dialectical approach, whereas the Reformed tend towards a mixed view. More on that later, perhaps.
Now, it is my position that we must adopt the dialectical view: the Christian is both righteous and sinful, at one and the same time, but not in such a way that we can relate righteousness and sinfulness on a simple sliding scale. Righteousness is not the opposite of sinfulness in the Christian life, or at least not in the way that this sliding scale involves.
Well, that was all pretty obscure wasn't it? Might make more sense tomorrow, but I confess I'm thinking this stuff through as I type!
Let me put down some foundations. It seems to me that there are two basic ways of approaching this problem, two ways of relating the Christian's righteousness and his or her sinfulness.
On the one hand, there are constructions in which these two things are placed on one plane. At its most crude, this is expressed as a sort of sliding scale. You experience a mix of righteousness and sinfulness because you are a mix of righteousness and sinfulness. You are partly righteous, partly sinful. Righteousness and sinfulness are, on this model, considered to be basically the same sort of thing, albeit the same sort of thing in an opposite configuration. Now, I would guess this view is hardly ever expressed in such a crude way as this, but I think we can detect it lying behind the traditional Roman Catholic approach, for example. On this view, baptism is the beginning of righteousness, the first infusion of righteousness into me as a subject. Throughout my Christian life, I should expect that my righteousness increases (with the concurrent decrease in my sinfulness) as I make use of the means of grace, especially of course the sacraments. Of course, should I neglect the means of grace, or entertain temptation in some way, I can expect the scale to slide the other way. This view has the benefit of being straightforward, making sense of our experience, and being practical, giving us instructions in dealing with our relative sinfulness.
Before any Roman Catholics jump on me for presenting their theology in such a crude, and frankly shabby, fashion - I know it isn't quite like that. But that is the tendency I see at the heart of it. Am I wrong?
The other basic approach is to say that there is some sort of dialectical approach to righteousness/sinfulness, something which places them on different planes, or at least which makes their relationship much more complex than a sliding scale. On this side we have to place all Protestant answers, which have typically stated that the Christian is in some way both righteous and sinful at one and the same time (simul iustus et peccator) without implying that righteousness and sinfulness can be considered as present in different relative measures in the Christian. The classic Reformed position, which sees the Christian as totally righteous with the imputed righteousness of Christ, and yet in themselves sinful, is a good example of this.
The two approaches - the straightforward and the dialectical - can be related in one system, and indeed probably must be. So, for example, the Reformed see a sliding scale in the Christian's worked out or experienced righteousness/sinfulness, whilst holding an ultimately dialectical view; the Roman Catholic sees the righteousness of Christ lying behind the sacraments in a way which cannot be made to slot into the straightforward view. Nevertheless, the two positions are basically different in their approach.
There is of course the Wesleyan view, which to my mind is just confused as to which position it holds. Probably it ultimately comes down on the dialectical side. As a historical note, you could argue that Lutheranism is characterised by a more pure dialectical approach, whereas the Reformed tend towards a mixed view. More on that later, perhaps.
Now, it is my position that we must adopt the dialectical view: the Christian is both righteous and sinful, at one and the same time, but not in such a way that we can relate righteousness and sinfulness on a simple sliding scale. Righteousness is not the opposite of sinfulness in the Christian life, or at least not in the way that this sliding scale involves.
Well, that was all pretty obscure wasn't it? Might make more sense tomorrow, but I confess I'm thinking this stuff through as I type!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)