Monday, August 21, 2017

Nihilisms

Every ideology with a nothing at the heart of it tries very hard to make everything else a nothing as well.  That is to say, nihilism annihilates.

Are we not surrounded on every side by nihilisms?

I am no expert on radical Islam, so you must take this not as a philosophical or theological analysis but merely a personal reflection; this is how it looks and feels to me.  I look at the giant monad at the heart of Islamist thinking and can't help thinking it's a nothing.  The radicalised monad sucks the value from all things, including life.  In theory this is because only the monad has value, or at least value-in-itself.  But is the gravity of the Islamist god actually the attraction of a black hole?  A nothing collapsing in on itself for all eternity, and all reality helpless before it...

Ostensibly opposed to this black hole, the re-emergence of neo-pagan blood and soil racism.  And we might play spot the difference.  In this quasi-Nietzschean cult of power combined with the whinging sense of perpetual victimhood of the spoilt child, what is there but emptiness?  The superman who is less than human, not even average.  Just a nothing.  Protect the white race, they say, protect our culture.  And yet there is no such thing, and in the sense they mean it there never was.  Burn your torches and march, burn your torches and pretend that you are light and fire.  There is a nothing in your heart, and you annihilate that which you claim to love but do not.

And meanwhile most of us here in the twilit West sit politely and drink coffee and worship the nothing.  Oh, we do.  We believe in nothing but personal autonomy, and to preserve our personal autonomy we have fed into the flames of nothing every sort of value and truth.  But in the end what will we have left to feed to this burning nothing?  Haven't we already begun to offer it the last of our fuel: our very capacity to choose?  To keep the world neutral, to maintain a space where we can be who we want to be, we have made a vacuum.  And now the nothing will take even our ability to be ourselves; we will destroy ourselves willingly, for fear that any sort of self might impinge on others.  The nothing collapses into itself, and we, who have become nothing, collapse with it.

1 comment:

  1. This very much strikes a chord. In my mind, Islam has always been pictured as an arid desert, and I don't think that's just because of the literal geography involved.

    What fascinates me is the doublethink involved, in Orwell's sense, where the aim is to get people to believe contradictory things: i.e. there is no truth, and that is the truth; morality is relative, but certain 'values' are absolute, etc. It's perhaps the best way to control the populace: keep them rooted in theoretical nihilism so they will swallow certain incoherent values in a desperate attempt to provide a modicum of meaning and direction to their lives.

    I think I've recommended this before - and I'd heartily disagree with his Sacralism these days - but Seraphim Rose's very short 'Nihilism' is a brilliant analysis. It's online if of interest:

    http://www.oodegr.com/english/filosofia/nihilism_root_modern_age.htm

    ReplyDelete